Skip to main content
←

Cost · 19 October 2026

How did the EU estimate the cost of implementing PSD3 and the PSR?

The EU estimated nearly €300m in one-off and €123m a year in ongoing PSD3/PSR costs. Here's how it got those figures, and why they look low.

David WormleyBy David Wormley

Summary

The EU estimated nearly €300m in one-off costs across the industry, plus €123m a year in ongoing costs, to implement PSD3 and the PSR. Those figures only cover open banking API upgrades, permission dashboards, payee verification and consumer education. Several large costs are left out, and some of the figures that are included look like significant undercounts.

The European Commission's impact assessment (IA) of its proposals for PSD3 and PSR estimated one-off costs for the industry of nearly €300m, plus more than €123m per year in ongoing costs. This article, which accompanies our piece on what the EU missed from its PSD3/PSR cost estimates, looks at what the EU's figures include and how they were reached.

Costs estimated in the IA

Here's how the IA breaks down its estimated costs for PSD3 implementation (expressed in 2022 euros and based on the number of active PSPs at that time):

Cost areaEstimated total costPSPs affectedCost per PSP
Extension of IBAN/name verification to cover all credit transfers€50m~1,250€40,000
Education campaigns for customers on rights/obligations, financial literacy, and fraud scheme alertsAt least €123m/year (recurring)1~4,000~€30,000/year1
Upgrading open banking APIs/creating new dedicated interfaces€190m2~4,000€20,000–€100,000 (average ~€47,500)2
Creating open banking permission dashboards€12m–€48m~4,000€3,000–€12,000

Issues with the IA's estimates

Those estimates are also incomplete. The numbers the Commission does provide don't inspire much more confidence.

Open banking permissions dashboards

One of the proposals priced by the IA was to require the use of permissions dashboards for open banking functionality, similar to cookie consent dashboards used for PECR/GDPR compliance. The IA estimated the cost of creating these dashboards based on quotes from GDPR cookie consent management providers (€3,000 to €12,000 per year for a subscription) and multiplying by the EU's roughly 4,000 credit institutions as a proxy for the number of account servicing payment service providers (ASPSPs) for a total of €12m to €48m.3 However:

  1. This is an estimate of one-off (build/implementation) costs based on the price of a single year's subscription to commercially available cookie consent management tools, years after their initial implementation (GDPR has been applied since 25 May 2018, with the IA published five years later in June 2023).
  2. The ongoing running cost of these dashboards, more comparable with the subscriptions used as a reference point, are handwaved as "limited maintenance cost" rather than repeating the number into future years as an ongoing cost.
  3. Cookie consent management is a much larger addressable market (most organisations with a website available in the EEA) than the market for an open banking permissions dashboard (around 4,000 EEA-authorised ASPSPs) due to the difference in scope between privacy regulation and payments regulation. Even holding the complexity and total build costs constant between them (which we'd see as unlikely given open banking consent dashboards' interaction with payment systems), that smaller denominator would imply a much higher per-firm cost than provided for here.

Payee verification cost estimates

Verification of the payee, where a payee's details are checked against those provided by the payer, had been implemented in several national markets by the IA's publication. The IA uses these implementations in the UK and the Netherlands as examples.

Although similar pan-EU requirements are now in effect for euro-denominated instant credit transfers under the Instant Payments Regulation (EU) 2024/886 (IPR), that regulation came into effect years too late for lessons on its implementation cost to be included in the IA. While these examples' availability means that the evidence provided for the cost of implementing IBAN verification is more directly applicable, the data is highly variable, making it harder to understand the likely costs at a per-firm level.

  • The Dutch implementation costs cited in the IA put one-off costs anywhere between €10,000 and €2 million per PSP, with recurring costs varying between a few thousand euros and €350,000 per year. The IA then picks a total "near the bottom of the potential range": €40,000 per PSP across 1,200-1,300 PSPs whose activities weren't in scope of the IPR,4 or about €50m across the industry.
  • While that's the same per-firm basis as used to calculate the cost of implementing payee verification on euro-denominated instant transfers under the IPR, confirmation-of-payee implementation costs were estimated by one UK industry body to exceed £40m across 400 or so firms (about €120,000 per firm, increasing with size/complexity: roughly 3x higher than the EU's estimate).

Fraud data sharing

While the IA estimated participation in fraud information sharing at a cost of €1,000 to €50,000 a year plus one to three FTEs, the IA excluded this from its final implementation cost estimates because participation was to be voluntary. However, the latest proposals would now make participating in fraud information sharing mandatory. Mandatory participation should make the arrangements work better, and shared infrastructure can bring the per-firm cost down, but it is another significant cost the IA never counted.

Applying more scrutiny to that estimate now, the €1,000/year baseline price of entry strikes us as unrealistically low, and the FTEs expected to manage these information sharing obligations add a significant cost in the hundreds of millions of euros a year across the industry.5

See how PSD3changes can accelerate and simplify your implementation, from the comparison with PSD2 and the EMD through to delivery.

See how PSD3changes helps.

Get early access

Read next in this series

Footnotes

  1. The IA pegs education campaigns as recurring costs for businesses. The figure comes from the VVA/CEPS evaluation of PSD2, which listed €123m a year as a recurring cost of PSD2 for credit institutions (Figure 14, p. 136). In other words, it's an existing PSD2 cost carried over, not a cost specific to PSD3 and/or the PSR. While the IA gives no per-firm figure or firm count, ~€30k a year assumes the same ~4,000 credit institutions the IA uses elsewhere. ↩ ↩2

  2. €190m is the IA sum for option 2c: ~1,000 smaller ASPSPs at €20,000 (€20m), ~2,000 banking-group entities at €50,000 less a 20% group discount (€80m), and ~1,000 complex ones at €100,000 less 10% (€90m). That works out at about €47,500 per ASPSP. The IA is inconsistent about this figure: the cost table calls it "options 2a+2d" and "€190 ml net" (p. 89), but €190m is a gross adjustment cost for option 2c; option 2a on its own is costed at €32m net (p. 41). The summary of the preferred option then gives €160m for the same item (p. 83). ↩ ↩2

  3. The ~4,000 figure is the IA's count of EU credit institutions. Under PSD2, an ASPSP is any PSP that "provides and maintains a payment account for a payer" (Art. 4(17)), not just banks. While not all payment institutions or e-money institutions provide account-based services, the 4,000-firm estimate undercounts those that do (likely in the range of a few hundred to 1,000 or so). ↩

  4. This figure reflects the firms who don't offer euro-denominated instant payments, as this requirement has been applied to those payments by the Instant Payments Regulation (EU) 2024/886. ↩

  5. Taking the EU's base case of one FTE for each of the 5,300 in-scope firms (payment institutions, e-money institutions and credit institutions), multiplied by a very conservative €50k/year employment cost, gets you to €265 million/year. ↩